Live Leps in the Classroom

William H. Houtz
From the Science Department
Pottsville Area High School, Pottsville, Pennsylvania 17901


Biology teachers, and most science teachers in general, are constantly looking for cost-effective, "hands-on" experiences through which students can interact with concrete examples of the concepts and procedures being taught. Lepidopterans, especially when the species are living and attractive, can provide just such experiences in the classroom. You can use living lepidopterans to show, for example, complete metamorphosis, adult insect morphology, and courtship behavior. You can also study the relationships between lepidopteran species and specific foodplants. In addition, students can simply appreciate lepidopterans for their living beauty (Fig. 1).

Lepidopterans belong to the Insecta, a huge class of arthropodan invertebrates. Commonly called moths and butterflies, lepidopterans are characterized by two pairs of broad, membranous wings covered with very fine scales, which are often brightly colored.

Lepidopterans show complete metamorphosis; that is, they go through distinct egg, larval, pupal, and adult stages. Their larvae, called caterpillars, have chewing mouthparts and feed chiefly on plants. The lepidopteran inactive stage, called a pupa or chrysalis, may or may not be surrounded by a cocoon. The adults normally have a tubular proboscis for sucking liquids, especially flower nectar.

Reproduction

Lepidopterans reproduce sexually with internal fertilization. Males and females are often distinguishable by color patterns or some other dimorphism. If it is not possible to distinguish the sexes by the observation of general body traits, you can examine the genitalia under a stereomicroscope to determine the sexes. Examine the ventral side of the end of the abdomen. In the male you will often see the claspers.

Female lepidopterans use chemicals, called pheromones, to attract males for mating. Copulation can last from just a few minutes to 10 to 12 hours (Fig. 2) depending on species.

In moths, ovipositing (or egg-laying) usually occurs immediately after mating. Depending on the species (saturniids work especially well), you can induce ovipositing; placing a female moth in a large paper bag with a few fresh leaves of the larval foodplant will usually induce the female to lay 100 to 300 eggs.

With butterflies, it is more difficult to stimulate ovipositing. The combination of sunlight (a sun lamp can be used) plus live plants (or sprigs of the larva's foodplant) - will usually induce a mated female to oviposit. Make a mesh cage the same height as the foodplant it is to contain. The female's feet touch the foodplant as she walks back and forth on the underside of the top of the cage. Butterflies have chemical receptors on their feet, and the constanttouching of the foodplant often helps tremendously in stimulating the ovipositing response.

Feeding

The feeding of lepidopterans presents an intriguing situation in that the larvae and adults eat very different kinds of foods. The larvae are herbivorous and require an acceptable foodplant be present. For example, the black swallowtail larvae eat parsley (Petroselinum crispum) or wild Queen Anne's lace (Daucus carota), and the cecropia moth larvae devour wild black cherry (Prunus serotina) or lilac (Syringa vulgaris). Adults, when they have a proboscis, feed on nectar in flowers, such as the butterfly bush (Buddleia davidii) or tall phlox (Phlox maculata). You can also feed adults sugar water or honey water. The sugar/honey water should be approximately three parts water to one part sugar or honey by volume. Place the solution on a gauze or paper blotter. Replace the solution about every three days because sugar chemically decomposes into undesirable by-products, some of which are harmful to the adult butterflies.

Obtaining Lepidopterans for the Classroom

Field-collecting lepidopterans in the cocoon or pupal stage is possible in some cases, but it is very time-consuming because the pupal stage is so well camouflaged. The field-collecting of adults requires netting them near or around their flowering foodplants. Unfortunately, since most flight periods of adults occur during the summer months, it can be quite inconvenient to depend on the capturing of lepidopterans for classroom use.

All things considered, the purchasing of living material in the pupal (cocoon or crysalis) stage is the most practical solution to obtaining lepidopterans. Purchased pupae can be easily stored under normal refrigeration.Adults can be induced to emerge in three to three and one-half weeks by moistening them and maintaining them at room temperature in a small cage or covered aquarium. If you use a covered aquarium, place some type of textured material on its sides. Cheesecloth or paper toweling is recommended. This allows the emerging adults to climb and cling to expand and dry their wings. Otherwise, deformed adults usually occur.

Suggested Activities

A number of experimental activities can be conducted with live lepidopterans. Each activity can be altered or enhanced to meet the teacher's demands, grade level, and time allotments.

For example, the complete life cycle can be followed on a day-to-day basis. The changes that occur from stage to stage - egg (Fig. 3) to larva (Fig. 4) to pupa (Fig. 5) to adult should be recorded in a diary. The diary should include dates, procedures, temperatures, behavior, and any significant structural changes that occur. Depending on the age and background of the students, this can be done as a class project or as individualized exercises that allow each student to learn as much as he or she is willing to do.The diary material then can be finalized into individual science reports explaining all the observations, or the class project can be written up and posted as a wall display.

Individual stages of the life cycle can also be examined in detail. Again, this can be done as a class project or as individualized experiments. Use a dirt-filled ant farm with two glass sides for a subterranean chamber. The class can study specific behavior - like ovipositing and mating, the spinning of a cocoon around the pupa, or the molting of a silk-cradled chrysalis. Adult specimens can be killed and observed through stereomicroscopy for both insect and lepidopteran characteristics. Adults can also be released once they have emerged and are dry. Many students find the releasing of indigenous species to be a very exciting and a rewarding end to the hard work of rearing the specimen.

Sideline experiments could also be done in seed germination and growing flowering plants. This would allow students to experience and learn about plant growth; the effects of light, fertilizer, and water on plants; the role of lepidopterans in pollination; and many other basic concepts. An additional benefit of the plant experiments is that you would be providing foodplants for the larvae or the ovipositing females and flowering plants for the adult lepidopterans.

Working with live, vibrant organisms, which react and change structurally, always produces a lasting impression as well as an informative, positive experience.

Further Reading

Collins, Michael. 1978. Wild Silkworms of the United States. Collins Radio Company Publisher, Cedar Rapids, IA.

Ehrlich, Paul R. 1961. How to Know the Butterflies. Wm. C. Brown Company Publishers, Dubuque, IA.

Ferguson, Douglas C. 1972. The Moths of North America (Fasicle 20.2B Saturniidae). E.W. Classey Limited and R.B.D. Publications Inc., London.

Tyler, Hamilton A. 1975. The Swallowtail Butterflies of North America. Naturegraph Publishers, Inc., Healdsburg, CA.

Villiard, Paul. 1969. Moths and How to Rear Them. Funk and Wagnalls, New York.


Swallowtail Butterflies

Add excitement to your classroom projects with living Papilio troilus and Papilio glavcus pupae. Order one species or a combination of species for unusual beauty and variation. The pupae can be stored for over three months in the refrigerator; at room temperature, they take about two weeks to develop. The adults can be used to start or add to an insect collection. The wingspan of the swallowtails range from 3 to 5 1/2". Available October through May.

   L 919A    Spicebush Swallowtail (P. troilus) Pupa . . $3.70;  3 . . $9.45
   L 919B    Tiger Swallowtail (P. glavcus)     Pupa . . $3.70;  3 . . $9.45
Now your students can study the life cycle of the painted lady butterfly (Vanessa cardui). The entire life cycle takes about 30 days. After hatching from a small, pale green egg, the painted lady larva pulls the edges of a leaf together and begins feeding within. After several molts (usually five), the larva hangs upside down and prepares to pupate. At this time the quiescent larva (known as the prepupa) is developing into a chrysalis (pupa).

After 24 hours, your students can watch as the caterpillar's skin splits and the chrysalis, which has formed under the skin, wiggles free. Within about four hours the chrysalis hardens and the adult emerges in 7 to 10 days. After emergence, the adult expands its wings and allows them to harden for a couple of hours before flying.

From five to seven days after emergence, female butterflies should begin to deposit eggs on the host plants. The small, pale green eggs, each with 12 to 14 longitudinal ridges, hatch after three to five days.

"Painted Lady Life Cycle BioKit"

For a class of 30. Enough material for each student to set up a culture with two larvae. Includes 60-75 larvae, culture medium, butterfly cage, 2 feeding vials, egg-laying discs, 30 culture vessels with lids, filter paper, 5 brushes, 5 wooden spatulas, 30 student guides, and a teacher's manual. Replacement Set contains 60-75 larvae, medium, 30 culture vessels with lids, 5 spatulas, and 30 student guides.

   L 914    Kit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $74.69
   L 916    Refill  . . . . . . . . . . . . $52.25
   L 916B   Replacement Egg-laying Disc . . $2.05

Painted Lady Butterfly Kit

Three to five larvae shipped in rearing chamber with food. Larvae pupate and emerge as adults in about 30 days. With instructions.
   L 912    Per kit . . $11.85

Raise-A-Butterfly Kit

Everything you need to raise your own painted lady butterflies. Includes five larvae, culture medium, plastic cage, water and food vials, climbing mat, and instructions.
   L 913    Per kit . . $19.98

Painted Lady Life Cycle Stages

Includes all stages of the painted lady: six eggs, five larvae (in container with food), two chrysalis (you supply hatching container), and instructions.
   L 915    Per set . . $19.98

The Butterfly Curriculum

Selected activities using the painted lady butterfly.
   L 917    Grades K-2  . . . . $9.95
   L 917A   Grades 3-6  . . . . $9.95
   L 917B   Junior High/AG  . . $9.95
   L 917C   High School . . . . $9.95

Painted Lady Larvae

One or two larvae shipped in rearing chamber with food. A larva pupates and emerges as an adult in about 30 days. Ideal for individual student use. With instructions.
   L 911    Per 3  . . $13.59
            Per 12 . . $49.98

Painted Lady Chrysalis

With instructions.
   L 912A   Each . . . . . . . . $4.55;
            3 or more, each  . . $3.85

Painted Lady Culture Medium

Sufficient medium for up to 80 larvae. In two 8-oz jars. With instructions.
   L 918    Per jar . . $19.50

Mallow Plant

The ideal host plant for the adult painted lady butterflies to lay their eggs on. With instructions.
   L 918M    Each . . $5.15

Butterfly Habitat

Ideal for maintaining two or three adult butterflies. Includes container with escape-proof lid, climbing mat, watering vial with wick, and instructions.
   L 919H    Per set . . $7.98

Explore the fascinating phases of Moth Metamorphosis with kits and living specimens from Carolina

"Tobacco Hornworm BioKit"

Manduca sexta. For a class of 30 students, working in teams of two. Demonstrates the life cycle of the tobacco hornworm. Larvae are shipped with enough medium and supplies to carry through the life cycle. Kit includes 15 larvae, 15 vials medium, 15 vial caps, 15 sponge plugs, 15 rulers, holding tray, moth cage, bag pupating medium, sponge (tobacco extract), sheet of labels, 30 student guides, and teacher's manual.
   L 907    Per kit . . $68.00

Tobacco Hornworm

Eggs are unrefrigerated and are for hatching tobacco hornworm larvae only. If larvae are to be cultured, order L 908M Tobacco Hornworm Medium. Vials of larvae are shipped with enough medium to grow the larvae to maturity. With instructions.
   L 907A   Eggs (30-50) . . . $8.75
   L 908    Larvae, per 12 . . $25.15
                    per 25 . . $45.75
                    per 50 . . $89.95
   L 908P   Pupae, per 6 . . . $16.40

Dry Hornworm Medium

Enough to feed 30 larvae. Mix with water and formaldehyde. Includes instructions.
   L 908D   Per bag . . $17.15

Ready-to-Use Hornworm Medium

A vial is sufficient for one larva; 1 liter is enough for 30 larvae. With instructions.
   L 908K   One-liter jar . . $22.99
   L 908M   Vial, per 12  . . $13.75
                  per 50  . . $50.60

Hornworm Pupating Medium

A liter is enough for 25 larvae. With instructions.
   L 908N   Per liter . . $5.75

Greater Wax Moth Larvae.

Galleria mellonella. This moth is easily reared, hardy, odorless, and can be handled safely. The culture is self-contained (50-75 larvae), and the moth will complete its life cycle in the vessel in which it is shipped. With instructions. Residents of HI, ID, MT, and TN must apply for USDA permit to receive this material (we will supply necessary information and forms).

   L 909    Per culture . . $13.95

Greater Wax Moth Medium

Enough medium to rear at least 100 moths. About 1 liter of medium per bag. With instructions.
   L 909M   Per bag . . $8.98

Moth Cocoons

From one of the large saturniid moths. Available from October through May. See permit requirements given in L 909. With instructions.
   L 910    Per 6  . . $22.95
            Per 12 . . $39.95

Saturniid Moth Cocoon Set

Six identified cocoons (three each of two species) of large saturniids. Available October through May. See permit requirements given in L909. With instructions.
   L 910A   Per set . . $27.95

All prices are f.o.b shipping point and are subject to change without notice.