HALE-BOPP- STARDUST MEMORIES
By Sean Henahan, Access Excellence
WASHINGTON, DC (3/27/97) New studies of the fast-moving Hale-Bopp
comet are providing valuable information on everything from how comets
move, to the origins of the solar system and life on Earth.
Cover Caption: Comet Hale-Bopp on 20 August 1996 observed
from the European Southern Observatory, Chile, during the monitoring
campaign to study its activity evolution.
"The increased understanding afforded by this very bright comet [Hale-Bopp]
bears not only upon the origin of these icy transients from beyond the
planetary region of the solar system but upon our own origins as well," said Dale .P. Cruikshank, NASA
Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, CA, in a commentary of a special comet
issue of the journal Science.
The new findings contribute to an emerging paradigm involving the
role of comets and the origins of life on Earth. The paradigm suggests
that comets - rich in the chemicals and
organic molecules essential to life- may have contributed to critical prebiotic
conditions on Earth some 4 billion years ago. These compounds would include
water, carbon dioxide and
nitrogen, along with more complex organic molecules. At the other extreme,
the new studies may help explain the destructive effects of comets, for
example, the catastrophic extinction of
the dinosaurs.
Hale-Bopp is unusually bright and unusually large. This has given astronomers
the best opportunity to study a comet's nucleus they have ever had. Comets
are believed to be remnants from the formation of the solar system, about
4.6 billion years ago. Therefore, learning more about comets can provide
important information about the materials and processes that formed the
solar system. Studies of the nucleus can also help explain the
composition of the comet and the nature of its ever-changing tail.
"This is a unique opportunity. We have never had the chance to examine
a comet in this much detail over this large a range of distance from
the sun. Hale-Bopp will probably provide the most revealing portrait of
the workings of a cometary nucleus since the spacecraft missions to comet
Halley" said Cornell University astrophysicist Harold Weaver said
Astronomers were puzzled by the comet's changing appearance, as it would
suddenly grow brighter and then return to its usual brightness within an
hour. Another challenge was to determine how the various types of ice in
the comet are vaporized. The standard model suggests that dust particles
and chemical compounds, such as carbon dioxide and carbon disulfide, are
all contained inside frozen water. As the comet nears the sun, it heats
up, vaporizing the water ice and releasing other material and dust particles
that are contained in the ice. The dust is driven off in a huge tail extending
millions of miles, reflecting sunlight and brightening the comet.
However, Cornell scientists discovered that these chemicals have been vaporizing
independently of water. While the vaporization rate of water ice increased
more than 13-fold between April and October 1996, there was only a two-fold
increase in the rate of dust being released. The vaporization of carbon
disulfide ice increased by less than three-fold.
If the standard model were correct, water, dust and the other components
should be released at the same relative rates. The new information suggests
the components are contained in
separate regions of the nucleus.
"The surface of Hale-Bopp's nucleus must be an incredibly dynamic
place, with `vents' being turned on and off as new patches of icy material
are rotated into sunlight for the first time," said Weaver.
Another group of scientists has been analyzing the comet with an infrared
spectrometer and camera attached to 200-inch telescope at Palomar Observatory.
Their studies show that Hale-Bopp has an abundance of tiny (sub-micrometer
size) silicate grains. Some of these grains are crystalline, in contrast
to the more amorphous structure of the rest. This means that the
grains were subjected to strong heating sometime in their history, before
they were incorporated into the frozen comet nucleus about 4.5 billion
years ago.
"Did the heating occur in the solar nebula, or did it occur in an
interstellar cloud prior to the formation of the solar nebula? We
can't say," notes Thomas L. Hayward, Cornell senior research associate
in astronomy at the Center for Radiophysics and Space Research.
Hale-Bopp's birthplace was in the cold outer region of the solar nebula
where intact interstellar grains could have been incorporated. "But
we were surprised to see such grains even when the comet was over four
astronomical units from the sun. We thought the grains would be icy at
that distance." (An astronomical unit is the average distance
from the Earth to the
sun, about 93 million miles.)
Most comets can be studied only when they are within 1 or 2 astronomical
units, when dust grains are warm. But Hale-Bopp was unusually active
and could be detected easily in the
infrared when it was still far from the sun.
The new information gives astronomers a basis for comparison to other comets.
This in turn could yield clues to the origins of the solar system.
The ultimate goal is to understand what the grains are made of and their
processing history. That would indicate the history of this comet,
which in turn tells us what the early solar system was like.
"Our hope is that these dust grains, from under the surface of
the comet's nucleus, represents what the nucleus was like billions of years
ago when it was formed," Hayward said. "That
could help tell us what the solar system was like as it was forming.
This is just another piece of the puzzle."
Other new findings:
-
It's a big bopper. Current estimates put the Hale-Bopp diameter between
27 and 42 kilometers, at least three times the size of Halley's nucleus.
- It's gassy. Hale-Bopp has an especially voluminous production
of gas and dust, which is greater at 7 AU from the sun than most
comets yield at 1 AU. This is at a rate considerably greater
than that of Halley and all other recently observed comets at
comparable heliocentric distances.
- It's come along way. Composition of the comet is consistent
with characteristics of long-period comets thought to have
originated from a region of the solar system known as the Oort
Cloud.
The research appears in a special issue of the journal Science (28 March 1997).
Related information on the Internet
Hale-Bopp Magazine
CNN Comet Guide
Hale-Bopp Links
AEŬReport: Life
on Mars (Aug. 7, '96)
AE: Stanley Miller
Interview-Origins of Life
|
|